It all started with a photo feature for Agence France-Presse (AFP) about the start of massive death of long-spined Diadema sea urchins in the Eastern Mediterranean basin seen off the shore of Lebanon as of the month of December.
Few hours later, I received a phone call from a wise man who decided to explore the economic service of long-spined sea urchins in Batroun. The man was worried because he didn’t want to be a contributor to the extinction of this wonderful creature. He was righteously driven by his wish to keep his business sustainable while avoiding to be at the root of causing a Vibrio food poisoning to his customers.
In fact, if Diadema sea urchins become extinct in this part of the Mediterranean, not only the economic service of this filter feeding marine creature will be washed away but all its other helpful services will vanish as well.
A couple of people from my circles, all living outside the little country, sent messages asking and commenting that those are invasives anyway “why should we worry? We should rather be happy getting rid of them, no?”
Then more and more questions flooded over through the virtual channels for that whole evening.
I had to package-fill some answers for a priming with the topic before I decided to delve into a more serious explanation.
Why is it that I am telling this story?
Here’s why you are now receiving this evidence-based knowledge about a creature that deserves a particular interest from everyone.
But first, let me put you in my shoes and in the work of the Water People Organization.
It is true that I am a photo-reporter working with AFP since the year 2010, covering news. However, within the news production there is much more than just conflict, demos, clashes and war. There is climate, environment, biodiversity and most notably there is a world that is largely unknown. This world lies below the surface of water. It is even larger in terms of surface area than land. I work in this world. I work underwater.
The first time I held my breath underwater I felt 30 seconds longer than a century. With time, practice and learning I now hold my breath and dive to work underwater documenting all what could be happening away from your eyes.
Before all this started, I became a scientist with my first doctorate being in pharmaceutical studies followed by a Ph.D. in psychology. I studied photography in the university too. Funny it is when my university students ask me sometimes if there is anything I didn’t study in my life. Well, there is a lot that I would like to explore but nothing could be as vast as living in the ocean.
My scientific curiosity and doubts brought me to question several claims, especially those related to water. I was fooled just like most of the general public with misinformation — the World Economic Forum considers misinformation and disinformation as the number one risk in its Global Risks Perception Survey over 2023 - 2024.
I decided to put all what I have been told about the water world to test and I discovered that, if not all, most of what flows around is fake. It should not be surprising though because such claims come from people who are not authorities in the field ; they are related to the underwater world from a single perspective, that of tourism.
What is the best solution in this case? Oh yes! I went back to study. I went to marine biology, oceanography, meteorology, climatology, geoscience, water quality and treatment, epidemiology, public health and many other areas of science to learn and adjust my knowledge on evidence-based facts. Now, I know but I still need to learn a lot.
I ultimately channeled all this knowledge into a master’s pathway in sustainable development and that’s where everything cleared out.
I got certified as a freediving instructor sometime before all this but was not convinced that with all the science I dove into I could transform to the tourism industry. I decided to combine everything and created the idea of a NGO. I called it the Water People. We do science underwater now. We promote sustainability, the real one not that of the misinformation. We also do medical research applied on freediving humans. You will get to know the Water People Organization soon and its annexed departments but now let’s keep the focus on our main topic, long-spined sea urchins. Oh poor creatures that suffered more from misinformation than from the parasite that is now killing them.
The Invasive species thing!
The term with which Diadema sea urchins are constantly being described is that of invasive species — as if they were alien predators coming to suck the brain out of our skulls.
Well, honestly, they are invasive in the Mediterranean up to our knowledge because there is no historic data that can say otherwise. What is this? Are they invasive or not?
Let’s take a look from environmental sciences to see. What is an invasive species? Invasive species are alien species — not necessarily coming from outer space. Alien, in this context means that they do not belong. They started living outside their typical geographic range. In this regard, we humans are alien species from the point of view of marine animals, by the way.
To be called invasive, a species therefore should be first alien and second they should expand rapidly when released in this new area mainly because they don’t have a predator to control their numbers.
This was thought to be the case of Diadema sea urchins, the long-spined sea urchins. By the way, there are several species of Diadema urchins. Those non-scientists who try to show that they know about them make the common mistake of limiting those beautiful creatures to one species that of Diadema setosum. That’s pretty much far away from reality. And this applies to the Mediterranean.
Diadema sea urchins are not natives to the Med. They are natives in the Indo-Pacific Ocean. The most probable route that brought them to the Mediterranean (as well as other seas and oceans) is that of the water ballasts of ships. Well, this would be the probable case if they were not originally present in the Mediterranean but nobody knows.
Wait! How could that be?
Let me tell you a very short story about such a case. I refer you to a species of algae called didymo commonly known as rock snot. Yes, snot! It’s slimy, that’s why.
It leads to a change in the species composition of river habitats, sometimes adversely affecting the productivity of rivers. It also has adverse effects on recreation because people don't enjoy walking through rivers that are covered with a slimy mucus-like material on the river bottom. Rock snot has become widespread around the United States and in many other locations in the world, including Canada, Europe, and New Zealand.
It was commonly assumed to be an invasive species, and presumably was transferred on the bottoms of kayaks, canoes, paddles, and boats. Canoeists and boaters were warned to restrict moving boats from one location to another to prevent the spread of rock snot.
What if rock snot was always in rivers and streams around the world, but in such low abundance that it wasn't noticed? There are two pollutants that come from sewage and household and farm runoff, and they increase whenever humans are present. What if human activity, leading to varying nitrate and phosphorus pollution, and also changes in global temperature and other factors, have led to the increase in rock snot?
What if it is not an invasive species, but actually a native species that has increased in abundance in recent years due to changes in the environment?
It appears that rock snot has always been in the Northeastern United States.
Back to the sea urchin!
Fine, don’t feel lost. Let’s consider that long-spined sea urchins are invasive in the Mediterranean. They have never been there before and they came through ships. Is that ok for you?
Another thing about invasive species is that they compete with natives leading to their possible extinction.
If in your part of the Mediterranean you have native sea urchins and Diadema started multiplying then you are not on the lucky track. They will be bloody invasive in this case.
The case of Lebanon on the very Eastern side of the Mediterranean is particularly different though. Native sea urchins suddenly disappeared decades ago long before anyone in this region have ever heard about Diadema. The Lebanese coast has been “free” from sea urchins for a long time until the long-spined appeared at around 2018, maybe a year before even. It was already in the mediterranean more than a decade before that but in other parts.
Well, so this creepy invasive creature has no natives to compete with and lead them to extinction in Lebanon.
Yes we need it in Lebanon sea and a lot!
Ah! But still, why do we need it to be present? And, well, we don’t have sea otters in Lebanon to predate on those sea urchins.
Well, I have discovered a predator in the Lebanese coast as I was leading a group of freedivers to train through the ecologic freediving approach of the Water People Organization. I went back to this discovery and reconfirmed it. Loggerhead turtles enjoy grazing on long-spined sea urchins in the vertical walls of rocks where the Diadema likes to reside. There is also another predator that I didn’t have to do with its discovery. It’s us, humans. Couple of years after Diadema appeared in Lebanon’s sea it changed its dull taste to something many now enjoy.
Yes we do eat Diadema sea urchins and this became their economic service in our coastal cities. Thank you Diadema!
They literally became our new natives similarly to many types of fish that “arrived” or were introduced to the Lebanese sea more than 3 decades ago and are now considered natives.
Did you know that cornet fish, rabbit fish and goat fish were invasive when they appeared in our sea? Now you enjoy their taste and their ecologic services without knowing about their history.
Therefore, no competition with native species is present and there are predators. What else do you want to use as a means to hate Diadema urchins and create fake stories about them?
One common story is that they increase so much in number that people are not able to put their feet in the sea without getting a sting. A little reminder from above is that Diadema have predators so numbers will remain within control unless the predators vanish. Turtles might disappear, yes. They are being killed ruthlessly by many. But, I don’t see that humans are disappearing anytime soon — they are more serious predators than turtles when it comes to the amount of eating and overeating.
A short turn to our recent history, some decades ago when there were still native sea urchins in Lebanon and I quote all those whom I interviewed “I would just put my hand in 10 centimeters of the sea and grab one to eat ; people were not able to step into the beach barefoot because of the abundance of [our native] sea urchins.”
I won’t comment on this any further. It is self explaining. However, I will add, that although native sea urchins in Lebanon were truly bothering with their closeness to the shore and presence at a dozen centimeters underwater lying flat on the seabed, we don’t see this behavior with Diadema. They generally are present in the holes of rocks, as deep as they can get inside. They are mainly in the vertical wall of rocks, in the holes. I have never seen one shallower than a couple of meters depth and I don’t think that we are all 2 meters tall to be able to stand on the seabed and get a sting by long-spined sea urchins. This is the case of Lebanon. Every country has a different story. Some are similar to what I described others carry differences. But please, stop faking issues about the Diadema sea urchin!
You now know one of the benefits of long-spined sea urchins for Lebanon. It is food, more specifically sea food. Keep that expression in mind as we are going to return to it shortly from the point of view of public health.
Sea urchins in general, and Diadema as our main focus now, are filter feeding vegetarians. They are vegetarians because they feed on algae. They are filter feeders because they eat by filtering the water around them. In this case, they are filtering the heavily polluted coastal waters of Lebanon — polluted both chemically and biologically. I am sure you know what I mean but just let me tell you that wherever you see abundance of fish in the Lebanese coast think about why? Maybe you should allow yourself to smell the water and you will know. There is practically no sewage water treatment active. There are sewage water plants here and there, but now many of them are functioning and how many of the very few that function truly treat the water before releasing it into the sea? I leave the answer to your smell cells.
Feeding on algae is highly important. This is because sea urchins are able to control the load of algae at the coast. With the increased untreated sewage water on one hand and the agriculture fertilizers arriving through fresh water at the coast on the other hand, algae develop heavily and turn to what is called as algal blooms. Those are dense green “stuff” on the surface of the water that are particularly dangerous when they develop. They lead to dead zones below them when they start their life decay process and leave the area hypoxic. Long-spined sea urchins take care of all that and prevent its occurrence.
Thanks again dear long-spined friend.
In Lebanon, generally speaking, there are no corals. Do you know why? Yes, chemical and biologic pollution. However, in other countries around and in the Red Sea corals flourish. Algal blooms compete with corals and lead to their death. Countries with coral reefs are so worried about the current massive death of long-spined sea urchins now. They don’t want corals to die especially that rising sea surface temperature is already putting lots of stress on corals.
Diadema is dying!
A parasite previously lead to the extinction of long-spined sea urchins in many areas of the world, far away from the Mediterranean Sea many years ago. In some places, it took more than 4 decades to see Diadema urchins returning back but still with difficulty after the endemic.
Now, the parasite arrived in the Mediterranean. It is starting to wipe out our “new natives” in the Lebanese coast. Dozens of Diadema sea urchins are seen dead. They could die inside their holes unnoticed or sometimes they fall to the sea bed. They lose the mobility of their spines within 2 days and start rotting. They are also eaten by sea scavengers like the fireworm. If no strain of Diadema urchins turns to be resistant, another extinction of the the long-spined sea urchins in the world is coming, this time in the Mediterranean.
A final note before I leave you to imagine what could happen with the extinction of our little spiny marine friend. When eating raw seafood, in general, one is at risk of contracting Vibrio in the form of Vibrio cholera, V. Parahaemolyticus & V. vulnificus and this could lead to an urgent hospitalization. Now add to this the fact that, as of now, you might be eating a dying or dead rotting sea animal and you will know that this compounds the risk of contracting any of the forms of Vibrio — in most of the times one might not be able to tell if the animal is dead unless the person saw that it fell to the sea bed or can detect a worm inside.
What should one do?
Don’t touch long-spined sea urchins in the Lebanese coast anymore. If you dive near them, make sure you wash and disinfect your gear after you return to land. This is not because you will contract a disease but because your gear and you will become vectors or transporters of the parasite and carry it with you to another group of long-spined sea urchins that are not yet affected by the disease. Stop eating sea urchins. If you own a restaurant in which you sell sea urchins, make sure you run monitoring and evaluation every time you harvest sea urchins to avoid having your customers get Vibrio and start shifting to another sea food on your way to a fast total stop of long-spined sea urchin harvest from Lebanese water.
You can help!
You all can help by acting based on the above behaviors. You all can help the Water People follow the monitoring of long-spined sea urchins that started back in August 2023. Simply note any signs of death or good health (hopefully) in a specific place where you went diving or snorkeling and report the place to the NGO by sending an email with as much details about the place and the state of the urchins as possible. Make sure you get a geotag and include it in the email. If you can take pictures of the creature it will be even better.
Our email is waterpeoplediving@gmail.com
You can also reach us on Facebook and Instagram. It’s the Water People Organization. You can also reach us on google by searching for Water People Organization or Water People Freediving.
Be safe, keep our water and its creatures sustainable for you and the upcoming generations and help us stop the spread of misinformation about long-spined sea urchins.
We are stewards of sustainability of the Oceans and all forms of water
We are The Water People
No comments:
Post a Comment